I know there's some pretty serious hatred thrown Peyton Manning's way.  From my persepctive, he seems like a solid guy, a guy I neither root for or against, but a guy that seems to have done things the right way. So, I get that people wanna rag on him, and that's their business.

Having said that, how anyone who has watched football even casually and is allowed to post opinions about football here could compare Peyton Manning and Trent Dilfer ("the worst super bowl-winning QBs") is so far beyond me that it makes me question the VS qualification process. Check this out:

Trent Dilfer Career Stats:

130 game played, 58-55 Win/Loss, 1759/3172 completions/attempts, 55.5%, 20,518 yards, 129 INTs, 113 TDs, 70.2 passer rating, played in 6 playoff games and had a 47.7% completion rate and a 66 passer rating, won the super bowl

Peyton Manning Career Stats:

266 games played (265 started), 186-79 Win/Loss, 6125/9380 completions, 65.3%, 71,940 yards, 539 TDs, 251 INTs, 96.5 career passer rating, won 2 super bowls.

No, Peyton Manning is not one the worst super bowl-winning QBs, he is one of the best QBs to ever play the game of football, certainly top 10 of all time, IMO.  The only thing I can think is that this comparison was made by someone who has a little bit of an "issue" with Peyton and might have had a little too much Budweiser last night! 

BBG