I didn't put him down.  I didn't discourage him.  I said he was a low rated recruit (to wit 2 star) we got on late (the last couple weeks and he didn't get an offer until the last couple days), he had few other offers (who else other than Arky?) after striking out on who we really wanted (do we need to go through the whole laundry list of higher rated prospects we recruited much harder for much longer that we struck out on in January-February?)

How about you and others in your little cohort stop chugging kool-aid and/or trying to make yourselves "feel" better by refusing to admit the truth and attacking anybody who dares speak the truth? There is not one thing I said that is not true - and we all know it.