So we have an interesting long on-going debate that when simplified down, is the Classic "Jimmys and Joes are more important than X's and O's". 

That said, we all know it's more complicated than that - It's Coaching, Recruiting, Discipline, Team Leadership, Strength and Conditioning,  Staying Healthy, Luck, we could make the list go on and on. I'm open to ideas but if we just start with these:

Coaching (C) - The staff as a whole in their ability to identify talent that fits their system and coach them up to get them to perform at their very best. It goes beyond that too in keeping them motivated, limiting outside distractions, keeping them focused on the next game, dealing with Parents, Uncles, Girlfriends, NFL dreams, Agents, Handlers, all that. Also, how hard they work, how well they work together, how they keep themselves motivated to put in the long hours away from their families, gameplanning, breaking down film, etc.

Recruiting (R) - Convincing an 17-year old kid and thier extended decision making infleuncing sphere to pick UF over UGA, FSU, UM, BAMA, LSU, OSU, TN, TX, USC (not the Chump one), PSU, OU, ND, Clemson, AU, etc.

Team Leadership (TL) - This is the team policing itself, leaders on the team in the locker room who get the rest of the team to tow the line, work hard, study film, eat right, go to class, get sleep, limit clubs and parties, not slap the pregnant GF. It can't avoid everything but the better the leadership in the locker room the better the team will be at reaching it's full potential and performing it's best on the field.

Strength and Conditioning (S&C) - This is kind of a catch all, because we also know the S&C staff are the only guys during the summer who get to "coach" the players. But this category is somewhat self explanatory. If our guys are weak and fat and out of shape, it shows on the field.

Luck/Other (L/O) - Some I'm guessing will say I missed something that others will think is important. So this is a last catch all. Would be interested in hearing what you think is important in the "Other" category. Luck too is somewhat staying healthy, or when you play an opponent who's star QB is hurt, etc.

So, you have 100 points to distribute. What do YOU think is IDEAL - certainly you can win with any mixture or disribution. Here's mine:

(C) 30% (R) 40% (TL) 15% (S&C) 10% (L/O) 5%