|
(EDITED BY AUTHOR: 2/24/2006 - 10:15 a.m.)
One of the duties of my job is "service to
schools". Most of the agents generally knock this out by volunteering at
various 4-H events because in addition to meeting requirements you can also
build up comp time since the events are generally held on the weekends and
evenings. Now to the point, most of the 4-H'ers down here are home-schooled,
and it seems that the predominant theme of their science education centers
on this myopic literal creationist view of the world. I was judging a public
speaking event last year where the kids had to discuss a science related
project they did. This one girl did a project on sharks. She was a very good
speaker. Articulate, engaging, frankly very impressive for a teenager. However,
she started talking about how modern science failed to realize that the earth
was really less than 10,000 years old, and sharks have only been around for
about 4,000 years. Now, the “content” potion of this speech is a good portion
of the overall score (like 40%), and I gave her a 0. She was clearly the best
speaker, and the other judges all gave her high marks. At the end, we (the
judges and the moderator) all had to confer, and they were all flabbergasted that
I gave her such a low score. I got into a huge argument with the moderator (who
happens to be a coworker and the head of the 4H program) about the reason for
my low mark. I told her, it said plainly on the program that this was a “Science”
project, and I could not in good conscious raise my score. The vast majority of
these home-schooled kids are very bright, and all have aspirations to go on to
college. These kids are going to be in for quite a shock when they get back
their first Bio exam with a big fat “0” on it, when they use the “young earth
theory” to support their answer on an essay question.
|